Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Water shortages, ‘four-gear gifilis’, ‘futtaru’ garbage dumps and ‘transshipment ports’

Waking up to the first cock-a-doodle-doo only to stand in the early morning sun for hours on end in order to fill a 5 litre container with clean drinking water is becoming almost an annual ritual towards the end of every North-east monsoon for Shameema and hundreds of mothers like her, eking out their existences in their small villages. Shameema is not from a war-torn Afghan village but from Maldives where per capita income is almost ten times that of Afghanistan. Her island of Mulhadhoo, registered home of 350 people, located in the northern Ihavandhippolhu of Maldives is one of 60 odd islands to which her Government is contemplating on supplying reverse-osmosis drinking water on board small boats, after a prolonged dry spell.

Like most Maldivians living outside Male, Shameema and the rest of the eighty odd residents of the Mulhadhoo store their rainwater harvested from their corrugated iron roofs in polyethylene kalhuhan tanks; dispose their waste onto a dump on the seaward futtaru side of the island; and defecate into holes dug, as-and-when-nature-calls, on public beaches or ‘four-gear’ gifili latrines.

Meanwhile an army of Maldivians, mostly men anointed by their mighty political parties and financed by deep-pocketed bigwig resort-owners are preparing for their ritual once-in-every-five-years onslaught on islands like Shameema’s Mulhadhoo. This year an unprecedented 465 of them, sipping Italian Lavazza espressos in trendy cafés in Male or savoring the taste of an exotic vilaathu-sherbet in one of Maldives’ top-class luxury resorts, are meticulously planning their onslaught. Their arsenal will comprise of, among other things, an ostentatious display of verbose rhetoric on democracy, human rights, accountability and several other clichéd but little understood terms. There will also be a fool’s paradise of desalination plants that would, so they say, ensure a copious supply fresh water to all the households; diesel generators that would keep the fans and air conditioners running in houses with corrugated iron roofing sheets exposed to 12 hours of merciless equatorial sun to create an ambience that could perhaps be the envy of people living high up on the Swiss Alps. And there will also be an abundance of brand new 6 cylinder Yanmar engines that would propel fishing vessels out to the vast expanse of the Indian Ocean to enable diminutive weather-beaten fishermen to catch a glimpse of the mythical ‘minikaaraajjey gaskara’.

Shameema is no stranger to the chicanery of the Machiavellian planners. She knows that in a few weeks time she would be unable to stretch a leg without poking either a ‘rayyithunge khadhim’ or one of their lackeys. And though Shameema portrays an outward sense of nonchalance, she has a secret little reason to celebrate as well: the ephemeral treasures that come along with the politicians. The last time she was very lucky to grab a handful of those notes adorned with pictures of ‘medhuziyaaraiy’. But she remains unimpressed and nonchalant. And so are the majority of the people of Ihavandhippolhu and the rest of Maldives, for their taste for fantasy desalination plants, diesel generators bridges and flats have been cloyed by countless empty promises on phantom projects like the USD 300 million transshipment port that the previous government decided to ‘build’ in Ihavandhippolhu in the run up to the last parliamentary election.

I recently asked a good friend who I consider to be perhaps my small country’s version of Jeffrey Sachs, if he has anything to say about our politicians and Shameemas. His answer is simple. “Don’t put the blame only on the politicians. For as long as we have 142 islands with populations of less than a thousand people, there is no end to the stories of ‘empty-kalhuhan’, ‘four-gear gifilis’, ‘futtaru’ garbage dumps --- and the ‘transshipment ports’ are only a phenomenon deployed, not perhaps to camouflage trickery or finesse evil but to keep hope alive in an otherwise squalid and desolate environment”. As someone who as a child only accidentally escaped from the world of ‘fenthaangi/four-gear gifili’ induced Ascariasis,; and after thirty years, is still morbidly terrified of those horrid parasites that, ahem, creep out of the rectum after a spoonful or two of that slimy abhorrent stuff called ‘antipa?’, I can’t find any reason to disagree with him.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

nice satirical piece. don’t remember reading anything like this lately on the mvblogosphere. The self deprecating humor is fun to read. looks like there's more where this came from ;-)

meekaaku said...

Naimbe,

Very good article. Just wondering who do you consider the Maldivian version of Dr. Sachs is. Is there is anyone in Maldives of Sachs caliber or a reduced version of him? Maybe Anni is similar in his spread of neoliberal polices, like Sachs did in the 90s.

But Sachs has since made numerous contributions globally and is very well respected.

Anyway, just my thoughts.

Anonymous said...

I take offense at the comments from "your version of Sachs" in that he is happy with the assumption about folk like us from the islands, having nothing to look forward to other than satisfaction in the false hope the country's politicians are churning.

At least here in Addu, most of my friends, family and peers can see through the smokescreens. We believe that the situation is dire, and do no take consolation in vacuous promises. At the same time, there's a growing realization that Investment is needed, irrespective of its source (i.e. Government, Foreign Donors, International Funds/Banks) in order to cultivate an atmosphere of pragmatism accompanied by hope.

Right now, I just can't decide what is worse; the bumbling clowns who are in charge of our Government or the dry, driveling humor of Ivy League elitists (including our select group of technocrats) whose derision towards "the rest"is a clear statement of the hopelessness we're in.

p.s. All your posts are really a good, fun read. Exception being this one, of course :P

Ayya Is said...

I agree with GodIsDead. Your friend the Maldivian “Jeffrey Sachs” is wrong. Why should we not blame the politicians? After all it is they who are keeping our people in 200 islands as small communities. Qayoom knew very well that as long as they remain as a few hundred people is isolated islands, they will remain poor and therefore be subservient to their political masters. So Qayoom never really did anything to change that. For 30 long bloody years he talked about population consolidation under different names like selected islands development, addu development, and I don’t know what not. But the 200 populated islands were maintained all throughout his regime….thanks to the good counsel of his brother the eternal Atolls minister for all islands. And now that Anni has had a taste of power he too realizes the importance of keeping people in 200 islands. So, he would also have no reason to change anything now. What do you say about this?

Anonymous said...

AyyaIs,

You got me all wrong; its not my intention to root for blaming any one group. Yes, I did say I can't decide which is worse.

But just the same, I am more interesting in seeing ourselves out of it than get bogged down by a cycle of retort/counter-retort.

Anonymous said...

Nice to see you in fine form my friend.

naimbé said...

Anon 10:29 - self deprecation was the last think on my mind. That tells you how good a writer I am. ;-)

Meekaaku – thanks. To tell you very honestly I’m not too keen a student of economics. Someone who is morbidly scared of calculus cannot be, huh? I don’t know much I know about the work of Jeffrey Sachs either. It just so happened that I read his “End of Poverty…” sometime back so while I was writing this post and on that exact point where I needed the name of someone who is an authority of development economics, for some unknown reason I had two names in my mind – Jeffrey Sachs and Amartya Sen. Havent read any of the latter. Lately, I’ve become a keen student of freakonomics...Levitt stuff. Great fun.

GodlsDead – Hope all is well down south. :-) My friend the ‘Jeffrey Sachs’ of Maldives isnt happy about the situation. And one thing I forgot to mention in my post about this ‘jeffrey sachs’ guy is that he has lately joined the ‘Machiavellis’ of Maldives. What can I say? Money – control of resources, power, my friend. insatiable. ;-). I only agree with his contention that as long as we are dispersed in almost 200 islands there is no end to the state of despair and decrepitude. Yes, I agree. Investment is needed. But tell me who in her right mind is going to dump money into our Mulhadhoos, Berinmadhoos and Dhiyadhoos. Even if you take the case of bigger islands like, say, Kulhuduffushi, you cant get too many people sitting on the edges of their couches. I remember from a trip to KF a few years ago, how women, boys and girls as young as 5 were picking up ‘boli’ from the reefs at low tide. Being the curious self-proclaimed ‘freakonomist’ that I am, I tried to make sense of the numbers involved. Here’s what it looked like –12 man-hours stretched over 3 days to get a kilo of ‘boli’ that fetches Rf16, depending on your luck! Economics of comparative advantage, anyone?

Anon 12:19 - fine form? Thanks, but have I ever been in any form that’s not ‘fine’? The word ‘fine’, by the way, makes me very happy. That’s a word Maisha (my friend’s 18 month old bundle of joy) parrots all the time. :-)

Anonymous said...

The two necessary conditions to change the socio-economic situation of Maldives.

1. All the the Shameemas their hunbands and chlidren alltogether get fed up and decide to board dhonis to come to hulhumale and start living their in tents enmasse.

2. The President just declare that all islands in Maldives that has populations of less than 5000 people are officially uninhabited. After that no schools, health facilities, island offices, courts will be provided in these islands. If they want these things they can move to bigger and more populated islands.

Looks like we dont have the balls to do these. So, lets not talk about GCE Alevels, universities, and foreign investments. All of us should just shut up. Anni cant do. he wants some flats to be built in tiny islands and now talking too big things like carbon neutral stuff. thats all I have to say folks!

Anonymous said...

Very interesting. Your skill in writing this kind of articles is amazing......may be you should start writing for a magazine ;-)

Anonymous said...

Oh yes, I have indeed witnessed you in much less 'fine' form :-) And hey maybe I can help you do a Levitt style calculation of the forex leakage on account of the substances many of our country folk seem to find so difficult to give up.

Khilath Rasheed - journalist and blogger from Maldives said...

Naimbe, this is one of the most enjoyable posts I read in recent times. As Anonymous at the top said, I am sure there will be more to where that came from. I am sure you were not deliberately mocking but sarcasm and satire are the most effective way to drive a serious message home.

I think the plight of Shameema is the "Divide and Rule" concept Maumoon copied from the British colonialists. Maumoon never made an effort to consolidate population and decentralise. In fact, he knew that the easiest way to enslave and rule people will be to keep them separated and concentrated into small pockets on 200 islands. So there is no way Maumoon, and the politicians who stood to gain from him being in power, can be excused for keeping the Shameemas of this Maldives in their current tragic plight.

Anonymous said...

Naimbey, this is good. But I have a feeling that you are retreating into safe areas. You used to write about more controversial stuff. Scared? if u are losing steam then why continue to blog?

Anonymous said...

anony 1:30 - true.

Khilath Rasheed - journalist and blogger from Maldives said...

Naimbe, some of my friends have said you are retreating into safe areas because you fear that you will lose your job if you become too critical of Anni's government. Well, if Anni really is sincere when he says he can take criticism, then I guess you have nothing to be afraid of. But in case, he fires you, I guess then we can have the satisfaction of getting a confirmation that Anni is no better than Maumoon as far as promises are concerned, and we can be clear in our decision when we go to the ballot box.

Anyway, I came across this interesting YouTube video on Will Jordan's blog. It shows the extent to which people will chose to live in self-denial when our economy is going down:

http://willjordanuk.blogspot.com/2009/03/wonderful.html

As Will himself said on that post, "There's nothing quite as enjoyable as watching a government on its way out..."

Anonymous said...

Hi Naimbe
Himeyn ingilaab has published the real deal behind the carbon neutral thing.Can you please verify the accuracy?

http://himeyn-ingilaab.com

Khilath Rasheed - journalist and blogger from Maldives said...

Naimbe, I think you will thoroughly enjoy reading this:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/food_and_drink/eating_out/a_a_gill/article5553843.ece

:-D